S-K's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Lilium]

=/ top 100? That's surprising...

I'm amazed something with just tweening is rated so highly, maybe it's a secret following of this artists work, the subtle nod to elfin lied or just a reflection of all the goths/emos/violence lovers around here. Bad this movie isn't before you call this review abusive, but one of the top 100 movies this also isn't... just goes to show what style alone can achieve in terms of crowd attention

[Wakarimasen. Ep 1 - Balls]

so so...

wow... I can imagine the hate mail from anti Anime animators already, although they should really try basing their knowledge on more then just shitty dubs in american.

Anywho I'm guessing you're not fluent in Japanese due to the really basic dialog which is fair enough, but you can't do a setup like a series with that angle unless you can keep up the Japanese or it's going to fall apart at the seams. Work on better jokes and your Japanese or try another flash movie angle that's easier to pull off... it's your call...

mackain responds:

tnx for the advice.
yeah i know that our japanese is not the best, but we are learning;) and dont worry, we already have the scripts for the next episodes so its not going to fal apart because of the languade^^
it's always nice to get good serious feedback from time to time

[Azumanga - Bonklers!]

hmm... =/

It was ok but it's hard to gauge the value of animation someone else did you've traced over. It's almost a case of you could do the same thing with a youtube music video version just with the clips themselves. Tracing does have uses for improving yourself there's no denying that, but basing a whole submission around it isn't really fair to the users trying to go for something fresh and new =P

[Olympic Love]

lol... always with the sex jokes...

That was kinda funny, I'm embarrassed to be classed as english looking at that shit logo but what else is new... but a newgrounds elite member on the frontpage with sex jokes? Wow... I've never seen that happen before =P

[Gorillaz Meet Sonic]

o...k...

Very odd combination to say the least which isn't necessarily a bad thing, but the choice of song just doesn't really bring it all together. Then again any crossover with something and gorilllaz is going to come accross looking pretty forced as they have such a unique sound to most of their music, reasonable attempt here but consider your music more carefully next time.

[:: Squirrel Songs IV ::]

ugh...

Squirrel Songs IV quite frankly is kinda taking the piss, sure the songs are 'different' then the last ones, but you're going from the perspective that because something worked once you can reuse almost the exact same concept again and again and again and it will still be funny... like saying squirrelly wrath countless times in one song -_-

It's not the first time you've recycled gags either *cough* foamy fan mail *cough* you're kidding yourself if you think it works because it doesn't my friend, the only people giving you 10s are foamy virgins or are die hard fans. Foamy is funny when he's thrown into new situations or does observation comedy (although I think pillz e owns his character for free but that's another issue), not "OH! that idea worked before I'll make another one of those!" or this ranting bullshit anyone can do that >.> I haven't lold at foamy since you done the black squirrel character! Even if an excuse to us race jokes was a bit of a cop out... and no that doesn't mean I want to see another race jokes episode try something NEW...

[Bad Guy Falls In Poop]

oh newgrounds you... XD

Not like newgrounds to put an animation test like this on the frontpage, but you seem to have become the most popular English flash animator I know so some newgrounds love came into it methinks, I'm not disputing the quality of the work, but it's not every day one gag from a movie/tv show/cartoon recreated in cartoon form gets put on the frontpage.

Wonchop responds:

Actually that title most likely goes to the Super Flash Bros. I need to be in more Legendary Frog collabs before I can compete with that. XD

[WebFetch]

o_O WHAT?!

The graphics were decent and it seemed as if you were building up to some awesome punchline... but instead the whole thing just turns to an advert -_- not cool... that's what advert banners and popups are for...

[Missingno Don't Save Etc.]

oh noes... gotta restart that shit XD

Wow... such a great idea twist on game cameos XD you could have seriously milked that for all it was worth but you barely scratched the surface of possible lolz, metal gear with it's mind reading guy would have been great to include somehow too XD "lets read your mind" it's completely clear... wait a minute... oh shit..." that kinda thing

[MK vs. SF 3]

*jaw drops*

ah man HOW THE HELL DID I MISS THIS!? These movies are truly turning insain now, but as long as they remain true to the characters ability's I'll never tire of them personally (meaning no more proton canon... please.... wtf was that shit...) the other thing that really let this down was chameleon saying akuma would be his masters sex slave... I mean... shit ... not only is it to insulting to mortal kombat players, but I would have been more surprised if akuma really lost after a line like that.

I've never seen lighting effects like the ones you use before and story wise you're fairly accurate to the cannon... but please... NO MORE PROTON CANNON SHIT! and don't turn too dbz on me either for the sake of the fans... because there is a difference @_@