S-K's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Sonic Vs Shadow!!!!!!]

meh...

I would've given you a generous 6 but I CAN'T STAND SONIC UNDERGROUND! Sorry to anyone who thinks otherwise *tries to stop himself laughing* but Sonic Underground was a steaming pile O'crap despite the reasonable animation it was easily the worst Sonic animation ever.

As for this flash I hope it's one of your first submissions because most of it made little sence.
Apart from the flashing effects and the pretty cool button for the credits it was pretty forgetable. But don't be discouraged keep practising with flash and another idea will come to you...

Susil responds:

I can't believe so many people hated that show! I thought it was one of the best Sonic shows ever. I liked the idea of introducing siblings and even the songs could be pretty cool. Cheesy at times, but mostly cool. They each had their own wicked instrument and Robotnik was not known as Eggman, the most retarded name for a villian ever. But that's in my opinion, and your entitled to yours. Thanks for the review.

[Dumbmovie, starring sonic]

"ha 12? 12! 12! 12!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! ^^

With this being the second submisson by you I've seen I'm really starting to like your humour and some of the fresh new ideas you come up with, mainly in this case that extra bit with the character deaths. I honestly thought I'd just be watching the movie the whole way through but you got some extra interactivity in there! ^^ It's just a shame the not brillaint sound and animation brings down the overall quality of the flash a peg or two; at times the humour is also possibly a little too random (the Beavis and Crullela (sp?) bit at the start for example) making the flash overall not everyone's 'cup of tea'. Keep practising, improving, producing good ideas and jokes and I see no reason why you won't become one of the flash greats on newgrounds!

RogerregoRRoger responds:

well glad you liked it :)
Yes from time to time i like to experiment with interactivity.
THe cruel de vill and beavis scene is inserted because i wanted to make a spoof about those slasher movies, where also randomly killing scenes are inserted, i had to explain that that guy from the pool turned into a killer no? Okay, the bob the builder scene would also be suffiecent...
Randomness is my style, i tought you would say the whole who´s your daddy smurf scene would be to much :S
I don´t know about sound, it´s kinda a mysterie for me, but the art and animation keeps improving, no worries about that :)

[sonic and other madness 3]

"you wouldn't hit a woman now would you?" lmao XD

I may like Sonic but you gotta be able to laugh at these things. The animation and sound wasn't incredible and you looked like you hadn't even finished the credits! However there was some great jokes in there, such as little suggestions like Knuckles being a perv, what shit characters Chris and Big the cat are and how Omega should never, ever have been given a voice. That was so entertaining for me jokeswise I think I'll look at some of your earlier work to see some more of your pretty good sence of humour ^^

RogerregoRRoger responds:

hehe, glad you liked it:)
Myself don´t mind Big to much but all my voice actors were..:S only sonic character i hate is Chris :(
and yeah, Omega´s voice is extremely annoying in sonic heroes.
Well if you didnt like the animation and sound in these one, i´m afraid my earlier work is even more horrible then..
But there is also a whole new big sonic movie coming up, sonic movie madness, and the first part of that trilogy should be done within a month..Depending on my voice actress for Amy(yes next time real female voice actreses instead of hig pitched male or my dyslexian sister :S

[HNT: Abusive Reviews]

heh

Guess someone was going to do a 'how not to leave shit reviews' flash sooner or later. I still stick with the belief that shit flashs deserve no praise though, and even deserve abuse if the flash insults the viewer, such as RCColaClock's Killbill parody... *sighs with relief* there is a god... Newgrounds did eventually blam that thing ^^

Not a bad showcase of the basics man, but hey keep your flashs funny and no-one will care =D

JujubeLock responds:

well if a flash is purposely bad with no entertainment value, then the best way to deal with it is not review it at all. Reviews on horrible flash only give the guilty parties the attention they crave.

[FF: Mixed in Balamb]

Cool Idea done fairly well

I never even played FF that much and found that highly amuzing, the drawing within flash was pretty damn good, being a basic flash user at present myself I still don't get how you acheive that drawn effect, but at times the quality of the drawings changed quite drastically making it inconsistent. The sound was at times a bit off and the jokes possibly a little too random, but give these some fine tuning and there's plenty of potential here for a series!

Toonimated responds:

Ok... many want a series... would be possible?

[Potatoes- The Old Musical]

My eyes! Careful with the text

Probably the most advanced thing on that was the little bit of low quality footage straight from the film. The rest was pretty forgetable and the song although an amusing idea was just annoying which lost the point of the joke. As for the text be careful with colour changes! You can easily cause a seizure for some of your flash audience if you went much more crazy with colour changes.

Valhalla responds:

www.wtfomg.com
www.seizurerobots.com
www.ieatdookie.cjb.net

[Eric'sDemented Project]

certainely different...

I like Your style of animation and some parts were amusing (the squirrel and the guy trapped in the room to name a a couple) but jesus it was too random ^_^" Try something more structured next time for the sake of the poor viewer trying to make sence of it.

AlterEgoZ777 responds:

well my otehrs are more sturcteured...kida..not really...o well...but thanx but i accidentaly sent in the wrong one...the original is under the improbaility factor

[I'm here........]

hmm...

Certainely don't think I've seen something that abstract in flash for a while, pad it out a bit more somehow and you could have yourself an animated piece of art... =/

P.S. If you wanna waste your time giving another reply thats nothing more then an insult feel free but TBH I couldn't give a shit. If you can't take critisim from the reviews post this on a site of your own. Granted this place has some idiots but if the submission is quality people will defend it, simple as that.

biblo responds:

I can take criticism. I just insult people when they say things like "omg this a piece of shit!" or "what the fuck do you think you're doing fag!?"